Landscape Recovery supports large-scale, long-term management of land for the benefit of sustainable food production and the environment.
Many of the 22 projects in Round 1 are now halfway through the Project Development Phase (PDP).
During this phase, project teams are required to finalise their plans for how they will work collaboratively to develop a harmonious space for farming and the environment to thrive.
We’ve continued to develop details and share guidance for projects in this round. For example, we recently published guidance on how projects could be governed and details on the mechanisms through which farmers and landowners could be paid.
Our ability to co-design this scheme is founded on open and honest relationships with project teams. As part of building those relationships we:
- held ‘discovery calls' when projects signed their PDP agreements, to understand their thinking and give them a chance to speak to Defra directly.
- held a face-to-face meeting with all projects in 2023, hosted by the Eelscapes project near Gloucester.
- have made our way around the country meeting projects to discuss how they’re getting on and what more we can do to help. These visits and discussions have been great for both us and for projects and we always leave feeling energised.
On 30 January, we held our second face-to-face event with all the project teams in London.
We had two objectives for this meeting. First, we wanted to understand the issues they face as they cross the halfway point, to help guide us on where we should focus our support.
Second, getting similar projects together to talk and share their approach where project arrangements might differ. For example, accessing private finance or managing different agreements with land managers such as tenants or commons associations.
The breadth and depth of knowledge present in the discussions, plus the ambition demonstrated by project teams, makes us feel privileged to work with them. We’re optimistic about getting into the implementation phase.
Working with tenant farmers and landlords
Earlier in January, the team visited four projects in the south-west of England. These projects are all working with a range of land managers, such as landowners, tenants, and commoners, making the projects more nuanced.
We want to make Landscape Recovery work in a range of contexts, especially where there is a diversity of land managers. That’s why we want to understand more about how projects teams are thinking about how to work with different types of tenure.
In the Axe Landscape Recovery Project, we spoke to a tenant who supported the project’s aims and emphasised how farming and environment improvements need to go hand in hand. They also highlighted that we need to understand the impact the project would have on his farm business.
In Killerton and Holnicote, we got to see the diversity across the project area and we saw the first steps of a collaborative approach between the landowners and the tenants, demonstrating the critical role of partnership and consultation – the golden thread that runs throughout the report from the independent Tenancy Working Group.
In East Dartmoor, we spoke with representatives from several commons associations about how they see the Landscape Recovery project and what would be needed for them to really get behind it and deliver for the environment.
We want to make sure that tenants and other land managers can raise any concerns they have about Landscape Recovery with us directly. To facilitate this, we encourage tenants, or anyone else, involved in or impacted by an existing project in Round 1 or 2 to let us know about any issues they are experiencing by contacting: LandscapeRecovery@defra.gov.uk
When emailing, please let us know which project your comments relate to. We will ensure all information is treated confidentially.
Capturing project details
Since signing their PDP agreements last year, all projects have been working hard to develop the details of their plans. We asked them to bring these details together into 6 documents:
- Land Management Plan – outlining the actions that will take place over the course of the project. This also includes highlighting existing agreements on the land, any legal rights on the land and the different types of tenure in the project area.
- Monitoring and Evaluation Plan – holding the details of what the project will deliver over the years and how it will be measured. This will also include the baseline information of what is currently on the land so that we know what Landscape Recovery is delivering and, where relevant, how it is affecting food production.
- Project Management and Governance Plan – explaining how the project will be managed day to day and at a more strategic level. This is where we expect to see things like the project risk assessment and how different stakeholders are involved with the project governance. For example, how are investors and tenants represented on decision making groups in the project, and how are funds managed and disbursed equitably.
- Business Model and Blended Finance Plan – a document that should contain details of the project costs, any private investment and revenue, what public funds are needed, and the structure of public funds.
- Stakeholder Engagement Plan – demonstrating how projects will continue to engage with stakeholders in and around the project area. This could include bringing in school children, engaging with volunteers, working with local communities, and how other organisations in the wider area are being kept informed and involved with the project.
- Site Access Plan – describing the existing and proposed access plans to the project site. It is especially important to consider project access alongside the stakeholder engagement plan.
What do we do with these plans?
With the information in these plans, we can carry out a range of assessments on the project. What we’re looking for is the confidence that the projects will deliver the outcomes over the long-term agreement in a way that is good value for money and involves stakeholders.
Our assessments will cover areas such as:
- Environmental - is the right thing happening in the right place? Is the project ambitious enough? Will it be resilient to climate change?
- Financial – is the project financially viable? Is it good value for money?
- Social – what is the impact on the land managers, such as tenants? How is it working with the community?
- Delivery – is it deliverable? Do we know what the risks are? How are risks managed?
We are building our assessment processes and will continue to refine them as they are applied to the range of project plans.
Once a project has made sufficient progress on their plans, we can start discussing the content of their bespoke implementation agreement.
Next steps
We’re continuing to meet and speak with project teams on site. The recent face to face meeting with all round one projects was a great opportunity for us to gather feedback and facilitate knowledge sharing between projects. We’ll be doing similar events with our round 2 projects later this year.
We are continuing to develop some key policy details as part of co-design, such as the implementation agreement terms and conditions.
We hope that in the coming months, we will start to see some plans coming through from projects, which will allow us to start building some of these long-term agreements.
We'll continue to blog with updates, so do subscribe to the Farming blog.
2 comments
Comment by Deirdre Beavan posted on
Is anyone keeping an eye on 'value for money' of these projects? There seems to be an awful lot of report writing and meetings and networking and visits to London going on and very little actual progress. I am concerned that the balance might be lost along the way. There appears a huge disconnect developing between the efficiency of this work and the direct, practical environmental work able to be carried out by farmers without the need for all this expensive bureaucracy. Am I cynical in thinking that it is the NGO's who have most to gain from perpetuating the process?
Comment by The Team posted on
Hi Deirdre,
One aim of Landscape Recovery is to show that environmental improvements and restoration works best when done at scale, collaboratively, over the long-term. Landscape Recovery projects that enter implementation will be securing a 20 year agreement with potentially large amounts of government funding. Therefore, it is critical that we have confidence in the project plans – this is what comes from the Project Development Phase, including demonstrating value for money.
Many of our projects include farmers and land managers, and we’re working closely with projects to understand what we can do to make this work for them and ensure they have the confidence to commit their land to these long-term projects. These projects are the first of their kind in England and we see the networking as an important way for projects to share solutions and lessons learned, and for us to understand what more we can do to support projects into implementation.
Hope that helps,
The Team